Need online help The Odyssey: Let’s also return to the question of Odysseus’ leadership style

Let’s also return to the question of Odysseus’ leadership style. Earlier we saw him make a near-fatal error with the bag of winds, (keeping its secret to himself and thus provoking some of his men to loose the gales’ power.) Note in this section (especially in book 12) when he decides to withhold or share crucial information with his men, for instance, Circe’s warnings about Scylla & Charybdis and the Cattle of Helios. Do these seem like good decisions? Why or why not?